This guide was built to help you understand the benefits of incorporating your DAO and how the process of DAO incorporation works. We help you answer questions like:
Why should I incorporate my DAO? In what geographic jurisdiction should I incorporate my DAO? What legal entity type should I choose?
Get all the information you need to make the best decisions for you DAO by reading this guide.
By
Leo Henkels
The world of Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs) has come a long way since its inception. As these novel organizational structures continue to evolve and proliferate, the need for sophisticated tooling to support their operations has become increasingly apparent. In this landscape of rapid innovation and experimentation, Mezzanine Labs has emerged with a unique approach to addressing the complex needs of on-chain organizations. This article explores the current state of DAO tooling, the challenges faced by decentralized organizations, and how Mezzanine's marketplace solution aims to revolutionize the way DAOs operate.
To understand the significance of Mezzanine's approach, it's crucial to first examine the current state of DAO tooling. Graham Novak, CEO and founder of Mezzanine Labs, offers a compelling analogy:
"If we were making like the internet analogy, right, this is like the late 90s."
This comparison to the early days of the Internet is particularly apt. Just as the late 1990s saw a proliferation of websites and online services but lacked many of the sophisticated tools and platforms we take for granted today, the DAO ecosystem is in a similar state of early development and rapid evolution.
Novak elaborates on the challenges facing the DAO tooling space:
"We've got a long way to go. Actually, there was a really great tweet from Toby Lutke from Shopify the other day, and Shopify, if you're not familiar with right, it's an e-commerce platform that was started very early on. He was trying to sell snowboards online and realized, okay, I can help other people start their online stores. And when he was going out to raise money, the common thing was, 'How many people are going to be selling things online? How big are these internet businesses going to be? How big is e-commerce going to be?'"
This anecdote highlights a crucial parallel between the early days of e-commerce and the current state of DAOs. Just as many were skeptical about the potential of online businesses in the late 1990s, there's similar skepticism today about the widespread adoption of on-chain organizations.
The development of effective DAO tooling is hindered by several key challenges:
1. Complexity of Organizational Needs: DAOs require a wide range of functionalities, from governance and voting mechanisms to treasury management and project coordination.
2. Regulatory Compliance: As DAOs operate in a rapidly evolving regulatory landscape, tools need to be adaptable to changing legal requirements.
3. Interoperability: With multiple blockchain networks and a diverse ecosystem of crypto projects, DAO tools need to be interoperable across different platforms.
4. User Experience: Many current DAO tools are complex and not user-friendly, limiting their adoption by less tech-savvy users.
5. Scalability: As DAOs grow in size and complexity, their tooling needs to scale accordingly.
Novak points out an additional challenge related to the rapid growth during the bull market:
"I do think this might be unpopular, some people—a lot of bad DAO tooling got funded during the bull market. When I say bad DAO tooling, I mean stuff that's nonsensical, teams that were not good, products that were not good, products that were not sensible."
This observation highlights the need for more thoughtful, sustainable approaches to DAO tooling development.
In response to these challenges, Mezzanine Labs has developed a unique marketplace approach to DAO tooling. Novak explains:
"So, what we're doing is essentially providing a marketplace for these types of tools. By 'marketplace,' I mean it has a unified interface, and it allows someone to connect to, say, Gnosis Safe and say, 'Okay, we've started an organization.'"
This marketplace model aims to address several key pain points in the DAO ecosystem:
1. Unified Interface: By providing a single, cohesive interface for various DAO tools, Mezzanine simplifies the user experience and reduces the learning curve for DAO participants.
2. Flexibility: The marketplace allows DAOs to choose the specific tools that best fit their needs rather than being constrained by a one-size-fits-all solution.
3. Interoperability: Mezzanine enhances interoperability between different DAO functions by connecting various tools through a unified interface.
4. Scalability: As DAOs grow and their needs evolve, they can easily add or switch tools within the Mezzanine marketplace.
Novak elaborates on the vision behind this approach:
"Now you have the question: What is our organization doing, and what tools do we need to do that?' So, these are the questions of how an organization has to operate day-to-day—the billing, the payroll, the fundraising, the invoicing. And so, what this allows you to do is allow your organization to start on a blank slate and say, 'Okay, I'm an event DAO, we're hosting ETH DC 2025, and we're going to need to issue tickets. Let me use this ticketing app. We're going to need to have a donation portal. Let me add a donation portal.'"
This modular approach allows DAOs to tailor their toolset to their specific needs and use cases, providing a level of flexibility that's often lacking in current DAO solutions.
One of the key aspects of Mezzanine's approach is the emphasis on standardization. Novak explains:
"The thing that is hard about this, and something that's very important to us, is we want to do it with a unified interface. So say that when you connect your safe that represents your organization, right now bouncing between a million different applications, you've got problems of access control, you've got problems of permissioning, and just simply differences of interfaces."
By providing a standardized interface and addressing issues like access control and permissions at the platform level, Mezzanine aims to create a more seamless and user-friendly experience for DAO participants.
Novak further emphasizes the importance of standards in the crypto space:
"And I make the argument that the most powerful thing in crypto is standards, right? The ERC-20 standard means I don't have to go launch an ERC-20, follow that standard, and they know, 'Oh, this product I created is compatible on this exchange, and this lending protocol, and this thing.' So, it is that standardization that is truly, truly powerful."
This focus on standardization could be crucial in driving wider adoption of DAO tools and facilitating interoperability between different platforms and protocols.
While Mezzanine's marketplace approach provides a framework for existing tools, it also opens up possibilities for innovation. Novak envisions a future where the marketplace fosters the development of more specialized and efficient DAO tools:
"The way we imagine this marketplace is we're not going to start with the assumption that anyone is just going to say off the bat, 'Yeah, we're going to use you for distribution, we're going to use you for monetization, get our product in people's hands.' Let's start by saying let's build a basic product for batch payments, for invoicing, for these things. But if we're doing our job as a marketplace, any of the individual apps that we're starting with, and letting users start with, will be supplanted and replaced by a multitude of other options that are narrowly specific for a particular use case, particular function, for a particular organizational type."
This vision suggests that Mezzanine's marketplace could serve as a catalyst for innovation in the DAO tooling space, encouraging developers to create more specialized and efficient solutions for specific DAO needs.
A key advantage of Mezzanine's approach is its leverage of smart contracts and on-chain data. Novak explains:
"The nature of smart contracts and on-chain data makes it a lot easier for these things to interact with each other. If I make the Web2 analogy, right, I've got Web2 products that intentionally build walled gardens and gated moats because that's how they defend their business model. Web3 is different. I can read that on-chain data, I can spin up a new interface for that exact same smart contract and say, 'I don't like your interface anymore, I'm going to use this other one, but I get to keep my contract that I instantiated, I get to keep my software.' So there's not platform lock-in."
Blockchain technology's inherent openness and interoperability provide a foundation for more flexible and adaptable DAO tools. It allows for easier integration between different tools and services and gives DAOs more control over their data and operations.
As DAOs become more complex and engage in a wider range of activities, issues of identity and privacy become increasingly important. Novak highlights this challenge:
"If you want to deal with FinCEN, you need to have an identity. That means we have to have identity products and identity primitives, but we care about privacy. Now, we need to have a zero-knowledge identity that's privacy-preserving, right? So this takes time to build. Identity is one category."
Mezzanine's approach to this challenge involves creating a base layer that handles identity, access control, and permissions, allowing individual tools to focus on their specific functionalities. This separation of concerns could lead to more robust and privacy-preserving DAO tools.
As the DAO ecosystem continues to evolve, the tooling that supports these organizations will need to evolve as well. Novak offers an optimistic but realistic view of this evolution:
"It is inevitable, but it takes a long time, takes a long adoption cycle, and there's a lot of primitives that need to exist and need to be adopted in order for them to occur."
This perspective acknowledges the challenges ahead but also emphasizes the potential for significant growth and innovation in the DAO tooling space.
Some potential areas for future development include:
1. Advanced Governance Tools: More sophisticated voting mechanisms, delegation systems, and reputation-based governance models.
2. Improved Treasury Management: Tools for more effective allocation and management of DAO resources, including yield generation and risk management.
3. Enhanced Collaboration Features: Better project management and coordination tools designed specifically for decentralized teams.
4. Legal and Compliance Tools: Solutions to help DAOs navigate the complex regulatory landscape, including automated reporting and compliance checks.
5. Cross-Chain Interoperability: Tools that allow DAOs to operate seamlessly across multiple blockchain networks.
As DAO tooling becomes more sophisticated, maintaining a focus on user experience will be crucial. Novak emphasizes this point:
"The lack of software creates inadequate organizations that are less empowered and have worse tools, and then those organizations, we saw the last few years, sometimes struggle. And the lack of tooling means that people go, 'I'm not sure if this is really going to be a thing.'"
This observation highlights the critical role that user-friendly, effective tooling plays in the success and adoption of DAOs. By providing a unified, intuitive interface for various DAO tools, Mezzanine's approach aims to address this challenge head-on.
The evolution of DAO tooling is still in its early stages, with significant challenges and opportunities lying ahead. Mezzanine's marketplace approach represents an innovative attempt to address many of the current pain points in the DAO ecosystem, providing a flexible, standardized platform for on-chain organizations to access the tools they need.
As Novak reflects:
"We're still NY, but we're getting there."
This sentiment encapsulates the current state of DAO tooling – there's still much work to be done, but progress is being made. The success of platforms like Mezzanine could play a crucial role in driving the wider adoption of DAOs and on-chain organizations.
Looking ahead, the DAO tooling space is likely to see continued innovation and development. As more organizations move on-chain and experiment with decentralized governance models, the demand for sophisticated, user-friendly tools will only increase. Approaches like Mezzanine's marketplace model could serve as a blueprint for future developments in this space, fostering an ecosystem of interoperable, specialized tools that can meet the diverse needs of on-chain organizations.
Ultimately, the evolution of DAO tooling is not just about creating better software – it's about enabling new forms of human coordination and collaboration. As these tools become more sophisticated and user-friendly, they have the potential to unlock new possibilities for decentralized governance and organization, potentially transforming the way we think about and structure collective endeavors in the digital age.
The journey from the current "late 90s" stage of DAO tooling to a mature, widely adopted ecosystem will undoubtedly be filled with challenges and setbacks. However, with innovative approaches like Mezzanine's marketplace and the continued efforts of developers and entrepreneurs in the space, the future of DAO tooling looks bright. As these tools evolve and improve, they have the potential to not only support existing DAOs but also to inspire new forms of decentralized organization that we have yet to imagine.
